1 / 3 today
⚖ VAR Verdict · Case #165

Germany vs Argentina

FIFA World Cup · Pre-VAR · 2014-07-13 · 1-0 (AET)

Wrong high confidence
Red card — violent conduct
🗳️ Community verdict — vote now 5 votes needed for verdict

OURVAR judged the referee's decision: Wrong. You're voting on whether OURVAR's analysis is right — not on the referee.

Do you agree with OURVAR's verdict?

Every vote helps sharpen OURVAR's accuracy — and we're grateful for it. The AI isn't infallible, and your verdict is exactly what improves it, case by case. You're helping build the VAR we all deserve. 🙏

Incident
Red card — violent conduct
Law cited
Law 12
Recommended action
Send-off — red card
Referee
Affected team
On-field decision
No card, play continued (Rizzoli took no action)
🎬 Spot another clip we missed? Suggest it — we review every submission.
Suggest a clip →

In the second half of extra time (~108′, 0–0), Sergio Agüero caught Bastian Schweinsteiger flush in the face with a raised/swinging arm during a challenge, opening a cut that bled heavily. Referee Nicola Rizzoli gave nothing. The decisive fact: Agüero was already on a yellow card. So even the most lenient defensible reading — a reckless arm to the head = caution — produces a second yellow and a sending-off. And there's a strong argument it was a straight red for excessive force. Either route ends the same way: Argentina should have finished extra time with ten men.

🔒 Premium

Read the full OURVAR breakdown

Sign up to see every key factor, the IFAB law clauses cited, and the frame-by-frame reasoning that led to this verdict.

Ask OURVAR

🔒 PREMIUM

Have a question about this verdict?

Push back on the verdict. Ask the AI 'why?', 'what about the elbow angle?', 'what's the precedent?' — and get IFAB-grounded answers from the same model that called the case. Pro 25/month · WC 50 · GB 150.

Discussion

You're posting as a guest — one comment per discussion. Sign in to post more and comment under your name: Sign up free →