1 / 3 today
βš– VAR Verdict Β· Case #165

Germany vs Argentina

FIFA World Cup Β· Pre-VAR Β· 2014-07-13 Β· 1-0 (AET)

Wrong high confidence
Red card β€” violent conduct
πŸ—³οΈ Community verdict β€” vote now 5 votes needed for verdict

OURVAR judged the referee's decision: Wrong. You're voting on whether OURVAR's analysis is right β€” not on the referee.

Do you agree with OURVAR's verdict?

Every vote helps sharpen OURVAR's accuracy β€” and we're grateful for it. The AI isn't infallible, and your verdict is exactly what improves it, case by case. You're helping build the VAR we all deserve. πŸ™

Incident
Red card β€” violent conduct
Law cited
Law 12
Recommended action
Send-off β€” red card
Referee
Affected team
On-field decision
No card, play continued (Rizzoli took no action)
🎬 Spot another clip we missed? Suggest it β€” we review every submission.
Suggest a clip β†’

In the second half of extra time (~108β€², 0–0), Sergio AgΓΌero caught Bastian Schweinsteiger flush in the face with a raised/swinging arm during a challenge, opening a cut that bled heavily. Referee Nicola Rizzoli gave nothing. The decisive fact: AgΓΌero was already on a yellow card. So even the most lenient defensible reading β€” a reckless arm to the head = caution β€” produces a second yellow and a sending-off. And there's a strong argument it was a straight red for excessive force. Either route ends the same way: Argentina should have finished extra time with ten men.

πŸ”’ Premium

Read the full OURVAR breakdown

Sign up to see every key factor, the IFAB law clauses cited, and the frame-by-frame reasoning that led to this verdict.

Ask OURVAR

πŸ”’ PREMIUM

Have a question about this verdict?

Push back on the verdict. Ask the AI 'why?', 'what about the elbow angle?', 'what's the precedent?' β€” and get IFAB-grounded answers from the same model that called the case. Pro 25/month Β· WC 50 Β· GB 150.

Discussion

You're posting as a guest β€” one comment per discussion. Sign in to post more and comment under your name: Sign up free β†’